skip to main content skip to footer

Reviews

I've only ordered there once and I can confidently say that if I'm going to eat out while in Squirrel Hill, I'll be ordering exclusively from New York Super Subs. No I'm not a friend of the owner. No I don't know anyone there. I have no stake in writing such a positive review. I've worked in the area for a while now and order out way ... read more
GyroMurphy via google.com - Feb 24, 2021
Phenomenal cheesesteak ... read more
justin perry via google.com - Feb 16, 2021
This place has a really great Reuben sandwich, I also had the steak and cheese sub and was also very good. When you order the Half a sub is actually a whole sub . Well worth a visit.
Sean Russell via google.com - Feb 2, 2021
Hi quality food. When you want to spoil yourself for lunch and spend alittle more, good place.
Justin Dearbeck via google.com - Dec 31, 2020
Excellent meat balls ... read more
RB via google.com - Dec 4, 2020
A couple really nice guys working the place. The cheese steak was amazing and the bread was on point!
C copeland via google.com - Dec 4, 2020
I stopped in today for the first time and bought four cannolis. They were AMAZING!!! (I said 'were' because I ate all four in one afternoon.) And I have no regrets. Had I not already eaten lunch, I would've ordered a sub. But since I didn't, I will definitely be back! Nice place and the young man who waited on me was also nice and ve ... read more
Leslie Garrison via google.com - Dec 4, 2020
Always good sandwiches and they are fast and efficient!
Maaz Mansori via google.com - Dec 4, 2020
Good subs ... read more
Eyan Noronha via google.com - Dec 4, 2020
Excellent italian subs and meatball subs. But do not order the lobster roll. It's pretty terrible.
Ben M. via google.com - Dec 4, 2020
Best Italian sub I’ve ever tasted. Fantastic Philly cheesesteak as well. Lots of food for a great price. I’m never eating at Jimmy Johns or Subway again.
Lauren Caddy via google.com - Oct 4, 2020
Fantastic service, and fantastic food... Highly recommend this place...You can choose between a 2-ft sandwich or a 1-ft sandwich, and the prices are reasonable for those sizes and for how much they stuff the sandwiches full of delicious meats and so forth. Excellent place to eat lunch.
salsa 56 via google.com - Oct 4, 2020
We had an Uber eats promo code and decided to try somewhere new and so glad we did. We ordered the super italian and my husband had the reuben. The reuben was easily the best we have had in Pittsburgh. Personally I don't love reubens but I would order it for myself. The super italian was huge and I will easily get 2 meals out of it. ... read more
Chynelle Everett via google.com - Oct 4, 2020
Giant subs and fresh and well prepped ingredients, 4 stars because the employee only cut one of our subs for us.
Devin Smith via google.com - Oct 4, 2020
Great food, good variety, not too pricey.
Tyrone Allen via google.com - Oct 4, 2020
One of the best Corned Beef spots in Pittsburgh! I ordered the cold Corned Beef...was perfect!! We also ordered the chicken salad sandwich which my wife loved and the canoli's were awesome as well!!
Dirrty Harry via google.com - Sep 4, 2020
Had a Reuben sandwich and it was AMAZING!! Can’t wait to go back and try the lobster sandwich. Huge
Had a Reuben sandwich and it was AMAZING!! Can’t wait to go back and try the lobster sandwich. Huge sandwiches and subs, for a decent price. Definitely check this place out!!
Josh Lux via facebook.com - Aug 27, 2020
Best meatball sub I ever had.
John Tantalo via google.com - Aug 4, 2020
Great subs!!! Very good bread and lots of meat.
Abe Crowley via google.com - Aug 4, 2020
Great service. Great food. Cannot complain in the slightest. Great new addition to squirrel hill.
Bert Cham via google.com - Jul 4, 2020
Outstanding all around. The sandwiches are big and the ingredients are high quality. The prices are good too.
Jim Boslett via google.com - Jul 4, 2020
the Service here was great, it was my first time eating here and they helped me through the menu and I got a fantastic meatball hoagie. 10/10 will definitely be back!
josh crist via google.com - Jul 4, 2020
Highly recommend! Had an excellent Burger on a gluten free bun. Quick and friendly service.
Paul G via google.com - Jun 4, 2020
Great friendly staff with huge delicious subs.
Eugene Yu via google.com - May 4, 2020
great food. spicy relish was awesome.meatballs are to die for
great food. spicy relish was awesome. meatballs are to die for ... read more
Marc Edward via facebook.com - Apr 11, 2020
Stopped in for my first time today and had a great experience. I work on Murray Ave so I’ve tried mostly all of the restaurants on the street. I’m not sure what took me so long to try this place but I’m glad I did. I got the cheesesteak which was delicious. The steak was amazing and so was the bread. The service I got was incredible ... read more
Oogendoogan via google.com - Apr 4, 2020
The best pastrami on rye I’ve had in Pittsburgh and amazing cannolis!
jayne allen via google.com - Apr 4, 2020
House super special was fantastic. The pepper relish really separated it from a normal italian sub.
rice talk via google.com - Apr 4, 2020
I ordered a pastrami on Rye with potato salad and it was absolutely delicious & very authentic. I really like the online ordering for pick up feature on their website. When I think Pittsburgh, & squirrel hill, this is the place to go. Excellent breads & deli selection. Highly recommend.
Samantha Myslinski via google.com - Apr 4, 2020
The food is very good. Had the Maryland Crabcake melt sandwich. Had a really good taste. Came with 2 sides choice of potato salad, cole slaw, or dill pickle slice. Will be going back to try the baked fish sandwich and the lobster mac and cheese.
Michelle Williams via google.com - Apr 4, 2020
The people who run the shop are very friendly and knowledgeable, and the food I got was OK but I think it could have had a bit more flavor in it, at least in the cheese-steak sandwich I got, other than that it seemed like a good place to get a sub at, and while it is a small shop, for the general area it is located in it is a normal ... read more
UserAJO1 via google.com - Apr 4, 2020
Fantastic place! The owner and the employees are very nice and it is clear they all take pride in their establishment! I had an italian sub with a spicy pepper relish that was super delicious!! They also have gluten free bread, and it is super flavorful and delicious!! Can't wait to go back and try more things on their menu!!!
Jen Kurtz via google.com - Mar 4, 2020
Nice place to drop in and grab something to go. Owner is super nice and they spin out your food quickly. Lots of great in house prepared selections. Pricing is fair and the portions are huge. Check it out.
Brent B. via google.com - Mar 4, 2020
One of my absolute favorite places. The food is incredible and they create there own homemade specials which are so good. The employees are some of the nicest people I have met in all of Pittsburgh and remember what I like and will have a friendly conversation when they aren’t packed. Highly recommend for anyone.
Andrew Pritko via google.com - Mar 4, 2020
Truly incredible hoagies and a friendly and personable staff ... read more
Kayla Greygor via google.com - Mar 4, 2020
Veggie sub is served hot with carmelized onions, peppers, mushrooms, and melted cheese. A very good veg option.
Max Hutchinson via google.com - Mar 4, 2020
Delicious sandwiches and also amazing gluten free bread!!!! Not just cold cuts - they also have me
Delicious sandwiches and also amazing gluten free bread!!!! Not just cold cuts - they also have meatballs, crabcakes, tuna, reubens, etc. Wonderful staff and friendly owner! Great business in squirrel Hill, just came this year. Definitely go check them 'aht!! I can't wait to go back ... read more
Jen Kurtz via facebook.com - Feb 24, 2020
These guys think outside the bun. Whether a mash-up weekly special featured sub using habanero-infused Hot Rod Honey sausage from local Pittsburgh Honey, to using straight up filet mignon for their two foot behemoths, NYSS is a fresh take on an old standard. 3 kinds of homemade meatballs on 2 feet of baguette? Check. Fresh Maine lobs ... read more
Lower Murray via google.com - Feb 4, 2020
Delicious modern take on the standard sub sandwich! A super sub is 2 feet long and filled with the best cheesesteak I’ve had in Pittsburgh. Quality ingredients, professionally chef skills and clean surrounds make this my new go-to. I can wait to try their Italian!
Sasha Liebowicz via google.com - Feb 4, 2020
Lovely service. Vegetarian options available. Beyond burger was good, but the patty felt dry. I would have preferred it on the juicy or crispy side. Will go again for the desserts which looked amazing.
Snigdha Agarwal via google.com - Jan 4, 2020
Food is great, staff is nice!
Sam S via google.com - Jan 4, 2020
Great food and great service in a great location!
Chandler Meadows via google.com - Jan 4, 2020
Excellent meatballs made in store. Would go again just to get a meatball sub.
Matthew Legler via google.com - Jan 4, 2020
Really good and filling subs plus a nice selection of desserts.
Vatsal Ojha via google.com - Jan 4, 2020
as someone from the New York area, this really hit the spot. one of the best Reubens I’ve had in a while 😍 also super nice staff, definitely will come back ... read more
Michelle Janco via google.com - Jan 4, 2020
I got the cheese steak and it was amazing. The guys here are super nice and take care of you.
Jesse Weichey via google.com - Jan 4, 2020
Homemade deliciousness. Layers of flavors making food you thought you knew that much better. Don’t be fooled by the unassuming digs and don’t forget dessert!
Amy Levenson Jones via google.com - Jan 4, 2020
I gotta say this place makes a great Italian sub. Seriously up there with White House subs in Atlantic City. I have been looking for a sub like this for 5 years in Pittsburgh and finally found it. To me it’s like finding Jesus Christ but way better. There pepper relish is off the hook. I eat here way to much and can’t wait to eat the ... read more
Brian m via google.com - Jan 4, 2020
Great new spot! Delicious food, big menu, nice portions, and a really great staff. A+!
Mat Thorne via google.com - Jan 4, 2020
just really good subs that aren't typical of everything else in squirrel hill. They also use as lo
just really good subs that aren't typical of everything else in squirrel hill. They also use as lot of quality ingredients (the steak sub is made of real steak...).
Levi Markel via facebook.com - Jan 1, 2020
Had the Hot Rod Honey Hot sausage special and it keeps me coming back for more. Definite go-to when
Had the Hot Rod Honey Hot sausage special and it keeps me coming back for more. Definite go-to when I’m in town. The meatball subs are fab!
Thomas Crews via facebook.com - Nov 19, 2019
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
GoogleMyBusinessFoursquareFacebookYelpZomatoTwitterTrip AdvisorYouTubeGrouponInstagramOpen TablePinterestZagatFlickrLinkedInTumblrTheKnotWeddingWire